Yesterday, after some reluctance, I called up the folks at ToysRUs and asked if they had the crib mattress I was looking to purchase from BabiesRUs. As luck would have it they did and I immediately drove over there to pick it up.
The reason this was so nice was because the closest BabiesRUs is about 50 miles away while ToysRUs is only 8.5 miles away. At this point I'm not up for a road trip. So it was a relief to find out I won't need to go. Whew!
Side Note: ToysRUs takes BabiesRUs gift cards!